A brief commentary on every game I played in 2014 (that actually was released in 2014) starts NOW:
Shovel Knight
It's really nice to see something wallowing in nostalgia that actually introduces some common sense to the formula, none of that Mega Man 9 "turn on the sprite filter because god knows we all loved that" garbage. It's a solidly designed platformer with a stellar soundtrack from Jake Kaufman, but what really cemented my approval of it was the fantastic almost competitive-feeling boss battles. With some tweaks Shovel Knight could probably work in a multiplayer deathmatch arena mode, which really is the biggest compliment you can give any action game.
Probably the game I enjoyed the most this year out of the given options, hesitate to call it my Game of the Year because it represents and indeed panders to a lot of what I hate about the industry right now, but it's pretty damn good.
Mario Kart 8
IT'S ALRIGHT, I just wish Nintendo had gone more in the same direction they went with Smash Bros this year and tailored the game for a slightly more competitive environment. The rubberbanding and pretense that grandma is going to want to play the game with you for some reason holds it back from being a terrific racer. I got Sonic & All Stars Racing Transformed for my Wii U this year as well, and honestly I think I might like that game a little more.
Professor Layton Vs Ace Attorney
The Phoenix Wright trial segments are FANTASTIC, seriously some of the best ever created within the Ace Attorney series. I love Level-5s far more traditional puzzle take on the evidence, giving you a very small pool of it with multiple uses and actually requiring firm understanding and sound logic to pass testimonies. The Professor Layton sections however feel a little phoned in, maybe the trial segments just steal the show from them too much, but I was disappointed by puzzles included. The ending is going to be a dealbreaker for a lot of people and pretty much murders any replay value the game could possibly have, which would be fine only there's no COCKING CHAPTER SELECT FEATURE TO REPLAY THE TRIALS DANGNABBIT.
Loved the music though, some of my favourite of the year.
South Park: Stick of Truth
It wasn't awful, but definitely my biggest disappointment of the year. The amount of good comedy in videogames is genuinely pathetic and I thought this game could actually be notable and potentially groundbreaking in some ways. Turns out its just an incredibly short, overcomplicated (yet bizarrely easy) RPG with far too much faffing around with items and menus, featuring South Park humour at its absolute worst. There's a couple of good jokes in it but for the most part it's largely references and shock humour. A shame to be honest.
Hearthstone
YES I PLAYED A LITTLE OF HEARTHSTONE. NOT MUCH. BUT A LITTLE
IT'S A BIT LIKE YU-GI-OH! BUT A 1000 TIMES LESS COMPLICATED, PROBABLY FOR THE BEST
Yu-Gi-Oh! Millenium Duels
I ALSO ACTUALLY PLAYED SOME YU-GI-OH! THIS...okay I'm done with that.
It's literally nothing but the Yu-Gi-Oh! card game but on the PS3...somehow it has really severe framerate issues. You figure that one out.
Bayonetta 2
I like it! Just not as much as you! There's a full review on the site go read that I'm on the clock here.
Ace Attorney Trilogy
At time of writing I've beaten the first game again, I still think it's pretty great! The added fifth case that was initially exclusive to the DS remake is especially great, there's a lot of great subtext to it (even more so now due to recent events) and it feels legitimately big, like all sorts of scandals and corruption and political intrigue is just all collapsing in on itself. Trials and Tribulations is one of my favourite games of all time too; and let's not talk about Justice For All. Takumi had about three months to write the entire game, cut him some slack.
I'm not a fan of painting over fantastic pixel art for the sake of a glossy "HD" release, but it still looks fine. It'll do. I'll accept it. Still wish the 3DS had better sound so I could blast out Cornered ~2001 harder though.
Ultra Street Fighter IV
I'm six years late to the Street Fighter IV party...and unfortunately I think that might be far too late to get started now. I do like the game a lot though, I can see the little touches Capcom made to basically build tournament hype into the engine that's made the game such a huge success. I'll be there Day 1 for Street Fighter V though, don't you worry.
Guilty Gear Xrd
IT'S SO BEAUTIFUL, anyone who complained about it having 3D models and running on Unreal has been proven to be dumb and wrong forever. Haven't played a lot of it yet, but I'll be putting in a bunch of hours in 2015!
Abe's Oddysee New N' Tasty
This remake's weird and I'm not sure I like it at all! Definitely doesn't have the same atmosphere of the PlayStation original, and the fact the controls have been "improved" to feel like a more traditional platformer doesn't seem like a great move when you're keeping essentially the same control and design. Also hate the autorun and dynamic camera angles, OddWorld's real cool though so I'll give this another shot at some point.
Captain Toad's Treasure Tracker
I only got it today! I'll review it properly soon! Let's move on!
Grand Theft Auto V
Grand Theft Auto in first person RULES, Grand Theft Auto V however still kind of does not. I don't think it says great things about the game that playing the same missions again but with completely different shooting and a new perspective made it way more enjoyable. The main thing I resent about GTA V on PS4 is it's actually kind of a good shooter now but it's still designed around a cover system that I wish wasn't there at all when playing this version.
Other than that, it's still GTA V, warts and all. I probably enjoyed the story even less second time round. Let's put it this way, when I played Grand Theft Auto V on PS3 in 2013 I had not seen Reservoir Dogs, when I played Grand Theft Auto V on PS4 in 2014 I HAD seen Reservoir Dogs. You do the math.
Super Smash Bros on Wii U
First of all, Nintendo's strategy to put the inarguably inferior 3DS version out 2 months early then market the Wii U one on how much better and necessary to have it was is a work of god-damned genius. I still don't know why YOU bought the 3DS version though, seriously what is wrong with you.
I'm not a fan of how Nintendo's analogue sticks feel with 2D games on basically any of their controllers, maybe I just suck but I regularly have issues with changing directions quickly in these games and mess up inputs a lot. This is the first time I've been in danger of genuinely getting into Smash though, it feels like a lot of work has been put into every character in ways that aren't stupid. Definitely another game I'll be playing a lot more of in 2015.
LittleBigPlanet 3
Another game I've done a full review of on this very site so GET LOOKING. It frustrates me to have to keep talking smack about these games, they're so close to being my favourite thing in the world but they fall down on the most important hurdle every time and I end up not liking them at all.
To paraphrase my favourite line from my review; "The most important thing with games based about level creators is making the game fun, there's a reason there's a thriving Super Mario World mod community and there isn't a Cool Spot one."
GAMES I HAVEN'T PLAYED BUT AM GOING TO TALK ABOUT ANYWAY
WWE 2K15
These are seriously some of the worst AAA games on the market right now, it's unbelievable and people should talk about them more. What amazes me is how they somehow still keep finding ways to take steps backward. I saw some footage of the PS4 version once and had to look up about 5 other videos of it to clarify because I couldn't believe how bad it looked, I seriously could not tell the difference between that and the PS3 version of 2K14 in gameplay.
But yea, these games are awful, and even the masochistic weirdos who buy them every year seem to agree WWE 2K15 was a terrible entry to the series. AVOID FOREVER.
Watch_Dogs
I'd just like to take this time to congratulate Watch_Dogs on its groundbreaking innovation and gamechanging mechanics. Specifically the amazing "press square on a traffic light to make a car teleport into reality and drive into another car" function, which was used so prominently on every stream and video I saw of this game it may as well have been the core mechanic.
Yoshi's New Island
People love to love on Nintendo, but don't forget that they semi-regularly produce garbage like this too. An utterly pointless spin-off of a SNES classic which only serves to make the original more forgettable and stomp on its timeless art style. Haven't played it and never will, hate it just for existing.
The Evil Within
When you get over the ridiculous amounts of technical issues it has (no small feat) it doesn't seem THAT bad, not as bad as some people were making it seem anyway. Shinji Mikami knows how to do jumpscares and there's still some real solid looking action in this, but the story and environments are just strings of magical nonsense with the subtly of a sledgehammer to the groin and embarrassing amounts of the game look like they were copied and pasted from Resident Evil 4. Still, will probably pick up the PS4 version cheap at some point and give it a whirl.
GAME OF THE YEAR 2014 TIME
Well, I didn't exactly fall in love with anything I played this year. But I did play The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds on the 3DS in January, which came out in late late 2013 and was better than anything I played this year. So I'm going to be an utter nob and just pick that and y'all are just going to have to deal with it.
HAPPY NEW YEAR